(bulldog was one that I was dogsitting for a friend for the weekend)

So I didn’t know that it was Elvis till the show came on and my first thought was this is going to be really really awful.

And Adam Lambert really needs to tone down the eyeliner and eye shadow

Crystal
Remains the class of the competition. Bluesy and just spot on. What more is there to say.

Andrew
Awful. If he isn’t gone after this week then I weep for the whole show. He has been kept around far too long and it is clear now that he has a little niche that he can do well and that is it. Maybe he will find himself someday and break out of his little bubble.
The main thing that was wrong with this performance was that he made a raw bluesy song into some smooth soulless karaoke crap.

Tim
Wow. I really thought he should have been gone weeks ago and he just nailed it tonight. Compare and contrast him with Andrew and you see someone who isn’t evolving (Andrew) versus someone who is starting to show that he is more than just a little older version of Justin Beiber.

Lee
A Nice performance. And as much as I don’t want that to be an insult it is. He does a nice job up there and he is hitting all the notes that he should be but he just doesn’t have “it.” Definitely a guy that will make the top five but really would I buy his record? Probably not.

Aaron
Oh please how is this child still in this. Walking around the stage as your “Dance” or movement during “Blue Suede Shoes” = fail. And really Ellen, at this point we are giving A’s for effort?

Siobhan
Not her best. She is Adam Lambert. No doubt she has the pipes but really that was just all over the place. I like her but I really just don’t know where she really fits in terms of making records and she just doesn’t have enough to be just “Siobhan.” Judges were 100% spot on.

Mike
Absolutely the wrong song. Mike is big and has a huge stage presence and Elvis should be in his wheelhouse. Great vocals without a doubt. Definitely doesn’t deserve to go home this week though.

Katie
One of her better performances. Still wont be sad when she leaves. She really just need to be herself and stop listening to all the judges. Again while kids under 18 might have the pipes but they don’t have the experience to really match up with someone like Crystal who is an established performer with seasoned life experience.

Casey
Good. Pretty much exactly what should have been expected. Perfectly fit who he is as a performer an hence should have been better.

Top 3
Crystal
Tim (Wow)
Lee

Bottom 3
Andrew
Aaron
Mike

If Andrew and Aaron don’t go home it is a travesty.

Top Five
Crystal
Siobhan
Lee
Mike
Casey

In that order. Really though Crystal is the only one who I really think deserves to win. Not really sure if that is even the best think for her.

Hopefully this site will turn into something a little more relevant going forward from here.